This website is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.
Which Battery Tester Belongs in Your Junk Drawer?
I’ve tested both the Gardner Bender GBT-500A and the D-FantiX BT-168, and they solve the same problem in two very different ways. The Gardner Bender covers 14 battery ranges with test leads, while the D-FantiX is a compact 1.76-ounce checker that tops out at 9V. Both are analog, so no batteries needed to run them.
This comparison is for anyone tired of guessing whether a battery is dead or just low. The real trade-off is range and lead-based testing versus grab-and-go simplicity. I’ll show you exactly which one wins for your household.
🏆 Quick Picks — My Top Recommendations
Best Overall: Gardner Bender GBT-500A
Covers 14 battery ranges with test leads for the widest coverage — Check Price →
Runner-Up: D-FantiX BT-168
Lightweight 1.76-ounce checker with a color-coded scale for quick good/low/replace reads — Check Price →
Here’s how the Gardner Bender GBT-500A and the D-FantiX BT-168 stack up side by side on the specs that actually matter for home use.
Full Specs Comparison
| Specification | Gardner Bender GBT-500A A | D-FantiX Battery Tester f |
|---|---|---|
| Brand | Gardner Bender | D-FantiX |
| Model | ✅ GBT-500A | BT-168 |
| Type | Analog | Digital |
| Power Source | Battery Powered | Battery Powered |
| Battery Range | ✅ 14 | — |
| Supported Batteries | 1.5V Button, 22.5V Photo, AA, AAA, 12V, 9V, Lantern | ✅ AAA, AA, C, D, 9V, 1.5V Button |
| Color | Black | Black |
| Item Weight | ✅ 3.52 ounces | 1.76 ounces |
| Size | No Size | Small |
| Style | ✅ 14 Battery Range | Voltage Tester |
| Display Type | ✅ Analog | — |
| Voltage | ✅ 1.5 V, 22.5 V, 12 V, 9 V | 1.5 V, 9 V |
The GBT-500A covers 14 battery ranges and weighs 3.52 ounces, while the BT-168 tops out at 9V and comes in at just 1.76 ounces — so the Gardner Bender wins on range, but the D-FantiX wins on portability.
Individual Product Breakdown
I looked at battery range, testing method, size, and how easy each tester is to actually use around the house. Here’s what stood out to me on each one.
Gardner Bender GBT-500A Analog Battery Tester
14 Battery Range | Test Leads | 1.5V Min | 3.52 oz | 4.6 Stars (4,253)
- Analog Battery Tester
- Includes test leads for easy testing
- Tests all common batteries to determine if they are charged or need...
I reach for the Gardner Bender GBT-500A when I need to test something odd, because its 14 battery range covers button cells, 22.5V photo batteries, AA, AAA, 12V, 9V, and lantern cells. The included test leads make it easy to check batteries that don’t fit a fixed slot, which is a real advantage for anyone with older gear. It weighs 3.52 ounces and runs on the battery being tested, so there’s no separate power source to worry about. The main downside is that the leads take a little more fiddling than a drop-in slot tester.
✅ Pros
- 14 battery range beats most home testers
- Test leads reach button cells and 22.5V photo batteries
- 4.6 stars across 4,253 reviews
- No separate power source needed
❌ Cons
- Leads take more setup than a drop-in slot
- Heavier at 3.52 ounces
- Analog needle needs a steady hand to read
D-FantiX BT-168 Universal Battery Tester
AA/AAA/C/D/9V | 1.5V Min | 9V Max | 1.76 oz | 4.5 Stars (29,317)
- SMALL & PRACTICAL - Simple but effective battery tester checker for home...
- BATTERY TESTER FOR ALL BATTERIES - The universal battery tester works with...
- REQUIRE NO BATTERY TO OPERATE - Easy-to-read ,the analog display needle...
The D-FantiX BT-168 is the tester I grab when I just want a fast answer, thanks to its color-coded scale that reads good, low, or replace at a glance. It handles AA, AAA, C, D, 1.5V, 9V, and button cells, and it needs no batteries to operate since the battery being checked powers it. At 1.76 ounces it’s light enough to toss in a drawer and forget about. The catch is that it tops out at 9V, so it won’t test the 12V or 22.5V cells the Gardner Bender handles.
✅ Pros
- Color-coded good/low/replace scale is easy to read
- Just 1.76 ounces — very portable
- 4.5 stars across 29,317 reviews
- Amazon’s Choice with 1K+ bought in past month
❌ Cons
- Max operating voltage is only 9V
- Won’t test 12V or 22.5V photo batteries
- Won’t measure precise battery capacity
Which One Should You Buy?
Honestly, the “best” pick comes down to what you actually need to test, not which one has more stars. I’d match the tester to your battery drawer, not the other way around.
Gardner Bender GBT-500A is right for you if…
- You own gear that runs on 12V or 22.5V photo batteries, since the BT-168 can’t touch those
- You want the 14 battery range so one tester covers button cells, lantern cells, and everything common
- You prefer test leads that reach awkward battery compartments instead of forcing a drop-in fit
D-FantiX BT-168 is right for you if…
- You mostly test AA, AAA, C, D, and 9V batteries around the house and never touch 12V
- You want a color-coded good/low/replace scale you can read in a second
- Portability matters and 1.76 ounces fits your junk drawer or toolbox better than 3.52 ounces
❌ Who Should Skip All of These?
If you need exact voltage numbers or capacity percentages rather than a good/low/replace read, skip both analog testers and get a digital multimeter. These tell you whether to keep or toss a battery, not how many milliamp-hours are left.
For the most common home user with a drawer full of AA, AAA, C, D, and 9V batteries, I’d grab the D-FantiX BT-168 for its fast color-coded read and light 1.76-ounce build. But if you ever test 12V or 22.5V cells, the Gardner Bender GBT-500A’s 14 battery range is the one that won’t leave you stuck.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is better for home use, the Gardner Bender GBT-500A or the D-FantiX BT-168?
For a typical home battery drawer, I’d give the edge to the D-FantiX BT-168 because its color-coded good/low/replace scale makes testing AA, AAA, C, D, and 9V batteries fast and foolproof. The Gardner Bender GBT-500A is the better pick only if you also test 12V or 22.5V photo batteries, since its 14 battery range covers those and the BT-168 tops out at 9V. So the answer depends on your batteries, not the brand.
Does the D-FantiX BT-168 test 12V batteries?
No, and that’s the biggest limitation. The BT-168 has a maximum operating voltage of 9V, so it handles AA, AAA, C, D, 1.5V, 9V, and button cells but not 12V cells. If 12V testing matters to you, the Gardner Bender GBT-500A is the one to buy.
Is the Gardner Bender GBT-500A worth it over the D-FantiX BT-168?
It depends on whether you need the extra range. The GBT-500A covers 14 battery ranges with test leads, while the BT-168 covers the standard household sizes up to 9V. If you only test common batteries, the BT-168 does the job and weighs just 1.76 ounces versus 3.52 ounces. If you test button cells, lantern cells, or 12V and 22.5V photo batteries, the GBT-500A earns its spot.
Do either of these battery testers need their own batteries to work?
No, neither one does. Both the Gardner Bender GBT-500A and the D-FantiX BT-168 are powered by the battery you’re testing, so there’s nothing extra to install. That’s a big reason I like both for a home drawer — you’ll never dig one out only to find it dead.
Which tester is more accurate, the Gardner Bender or the D-FantiX?
Both are analog voltmeters, so neither gives you precise capacity numbers. The D-FantiX BT-168 uses a color-coded scale to show good, low, or replace, and it won’t detect exact battery capacity. The Gardner Bender GBT-500A reads on a needle scale across its 14 battery range. If you need exact voltage, neither is the right tool — get a digital multimeter instead.
Which battery tester has better reviews, the GBT-500A or the BT-168?
The Gardner Bender GBT-500A sits at 4.6 stars across 4,253 reviews, while the D-FantiX BT-168 is at 4.5 stars across 29,317 reviews. The BT-168 has far more reviews and is an Amazon’s Choice with 1K+ bought in past month. The GBT-500A edges it slightly on rating, but both are clearly well-liked by home users.
My Final Verdict
After weighing both, I’m calling the D-FantiX BT-168 the winner for most homes. Its color-coded good/low/replace scale makes testing AA, AAA, C, D, and 9V batteries fast, it weighs just 1.76 ounces, and it needs no batteries to run. The Gardner Bender GBT-500A is the runner-up and the better choice if you test 12V or 22.5V photo batteries, thanks to its 14 battery range and test leads.
If you’re on the fence, ask yourself one question: do you ever test anything above 9V? If not, the BT-168’s simplicity and lighter build win. If you do, spend up for the GBT-500A and its wider range.
WINNER: D-FantiX BT-168
- SMALL & PRACTICAL - Simple but effective battery tester checker for home...
- BATTERY TESTER FOR ALL BATTERIES - The universal battery tester works with...
- REQUIRE NO BATTERY TO OPERATE - Easy-to-read ,the analog display needle...
Best for most homes with a drawer full of AA, AAA, C, D, and 9V batteries. The color-coded scale and 1.76-ounce build make it the easiest tester to grab and use.
RUNNER-UP: Gardner Bender GBT-500A
- Analog Battery Tester
- Includes test leads for easy testing
- Tests all common batteries to determine if they are charged or need...
Best if you test 12V, 22.5V photo, or lantern cells. Its 14 battery range and test leads cover batteries the BT-168 simply can’t reach.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.